Benched or Left Off the Roster? What to Do Next

Getting benched, subbed off early or left off the game-day roster is one of the most common setbacks in soccer, and one of the most frustrating, especially for players who put in the work. The best response follows the same order every time: let the emotions settle, don't try to change the coach's mind, then ask the coach what you need to work on. Handled that way, a benching becomes useful feedback and a better relationship with your coach.

This post covers what to do in the first 24 hours, how to ask for feedback and more playing time, what to do when a coach says you're not ready to move up, and how parents can help.

This post is part of our guide to the mental side of soccer.

The first 24 hours

Feel it, but don't act on it

Anger, disappointment and confusion are normal. You've done the extra reps and the work nobody sees, and the coach still left you out. Those feelings don't need to be pushed away. They just shouldn't drive what you do next.

The worst time to talk to the coach is right after it happens. If you're subbed off, the coach is still managing the game for the whole team, and you're too heated to hear an answer anyway. Storming off or sulking on the bench sends a message too, and not the one you want. A good rule of thumb is to wait at least 24 hours after the game before reaching out.

Don't try to change the coach's mind

It's natural to think the coach made a mistake and just needs reminding how hard you work. But just as arguing with a referee doesn't change a call, arguing with a coach usually convinces them they were right. Accepting the decision doesn't mean you have to like it. It means you're choosing to put your energy into what you can control.

How to talk to your coach

Once you've cooled down, ask for a short conversation, ideally after a training session when the coach has a few minutes. Go yourself. Whatever your age, coaches respect players who speak for themselves rather than sending a parent.

Go in curious, not combative. Assume the coach had reasons. Whether they were right isn't the point of the conversation. The point is to find out what they want to see.

Questions that work:

  • "Is there anything I can do to improve and earn more opportunities this season?"

  • "Are there specific skills or areas you want me to focus on in training?"

  • "Is there anything you'd like me to work on away from training?"

  • "I'm working hard in training. What would help me get back on the field?"

None of these say "I want to play more," and all of them get you the information you need to play more.

Some players worry that asking will make things worse. It rarely does if the tone is right. Keep it brief, thank the coach for their time, and don't bring up teammates who are playing ahead of you. The conversation is about you and what you can control.

Then act on what you hear. If the coach says your defending in transition needs work, make that your focus in every session and on your own. Coaches notice when feedback turns into change.

This conversation does more than tell you what to fix. It shows the coach you're coachable, that you can hear criticism without getting defensive, and that they don't need to worry about how you'll react to the next challenge. Coaches tend to invest more in players like that. For more on handling harder conversations, see our guide on difficult conversations with your coach.

Use the time on the bench

Minutes off the field don't have to be wasted. Watch the player in your position closely: where they receive the ball, how they defend in transition, what the coach praises them for. When you do get on, stay ready. Warm up properly when told, follow the game so you know the score and the shape, and make your first action a simple, positive one. Coaches remember the player who comes off the bench sharp.

When the coach says you're not ready for the next level

A related setback: you feel ready to move up, to an older age group, the club's top team or an MLS academy, and the coach or technical director disagrees.

Ask why, politely, and listen. There's often a reason you can't see from the outside. The team above may already have a player in your position the club is developing. The physical jump to the older age group may be big enough that the club wants you stronger first. That feedback is valuable even if you don't like it.

Know what moving up means. Players often push hard to reach the next level and then ease off once they get there. The next level asks for more work, not less. Going up before you're ready for that can stall you.

Look at your long-term goals objectively. Is your current team holding you back? Sometimes the higher team's competition or college visibility makes a real difference. Sometimes there's still plenty of room to grow where you are, especially if you add individual training and take charge of your own college pathway instead of leaving it to the club.

Don't burn bridges. If you decide to move on, leave on good terms. Coaches and directors change jobs too, into pro academies, college programs and other clubs. The soccer community is smaller than it looks, and it gets smaller the higher you go.

What parents can do

  • Let your player lead the conversation with the coach. Help them prepare the questions, but don't make the call or send the email for them.

  • Don't vent about the coach in front of your player. It gives them a reason to stop listening to the person who decides playing time.

  • Ask how they're feeling before asking what happened. The analysis can wait until the next day.

  • Help them track progress. Once the coach names one or two areas to work on, help your player set small weekly goals around them.

If the setback is bigger, like being cut from the team, our post on being cut from a soccer team covers how to rebuild from there.

Setbacks are part of the path

Every player who has reached a high level has been benched, subbed off early or told they weren't ready. What separated them was how they responded: calmly, with a plan, and without letting one decision define them.

Learning that response early is one of the most useful things a young player can do, and it's a big part of what we work on in mentoring. If your player is struggling with playing time or a recent setback, book an intro session and we can talk through it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Michael Parkhurst

Michael Parkhurst is an MLS Cup Champion, MLS Defender of the Year, former U.S. Men's National Team player, and co-founder of Beyond Goals Mentoring, where he helps young athletes develop their soccer IQ, navigate club and college recruiting, and compete at higher levels of the game.

Previous
Previous

What Is a Mindset Coach, and Does Your Soccer Player Need One?

Next
Next

How to Calm Pre-Game Nerves in Youth Soccer